Conservation // 5 min Read

Then & Now: The Bluffton Historical Preservation Society Tells Bluffton’s Story

Written by Palmetto Bluff

May 10, 2016

On June 4, 1863, the quiet history of the sleepy planter’s town of Bluffton was forever divided into two chapters. As Union forces invaded the small Southern town, setting a torch to what had been a retreat for wealthy planters, Bluffton’s story was neatly segmented into what it was before the Civil War burning, and what it was after the burning.

It’s believed that Bluffton was targeted by such a vengeful military occupation not for any strategic purpose, but rather as retribution for a less literal fire set long before that. The secession movement, which saw South Carolina break ties with the United States of America, had its roots in anti-Union sentiment that had for years been called “The Bluffton Movement.”

The movement would eventually spark the Civil War, and bring the fire of Union forces down on Bluffton in dramatic fashion. Just 15 buildings survived that evening’s wrathful Northern incursion, 15 buildings that would dwindle to 10 as decay and neglect returned them to the earth. The fact that those 10 buildings are still remaining can almost entirely be attributed to the tireless efforts of the Bluffton Historical Preservation Society (BHPS).

In fact, the BHPS calls one of those historic 10 buildings home, making its headquarters in the beautiful Heyward House Historic Center. The structure bears the scars of Northern incursion in the form of a carved message from a New York soldier in one of its rooms, but otherwise escaped the torches unscathed. It has been lovingly restored by the society over the years and is now a must-see for history lovers visiting Bluffton.

It’s not just a beautiful place to hang a shingle; BHPS Director Jeff Fulgham considers the restoration of the Heyward House to be among the society’s greatest accomplishments. “There have been a number of great accomplishments by many individuals, but I would have to say that transforming an old house into a functioning museum was one of the biggest,” he said. “Past executive director, Robert Jones, Jr., accomplished this and a number of other things during his time as director.”

Fulgham, a military veteran and Bluffton native, joined the society as directory on April 1, 2015. “I always enjoyed exploring and learning, and when I joined the military and began deploying I became interested in world history,” he said. “When I realized I knew more about ancient Egypt than my own home town, I figured I needed to research and write about Bluffton.”[vc_single_image image=”6035″ img_size=”full” css=”.vc_custom_1462891994144{padding-top: 10px !important;padding-bottom: 10px !important;}”]That growing passion for Bluffton’s history led Fulgham to write The Bluffton Expedition, a meticulously researched and thoroughly engrossing account of that fateful June night in 1863. It also made him a perfect fit to serve as director of a society whose own mission was in a moment of evolution.

The Bluffton Historical Preservation Society begin in 1981, a year that in itself is slipping into ancient history. Bluffton native W. Hunter Saussy and a handful of like-minded locals realized that as the growth on nearby Hilton Head could potentially spill over into their little town, there was a need to catalogue what Bluffton was and what it had been before it was changed forever. The society’s mission was simpler in the beginning, as each member gathered their own small fragments of town history – family photos, newspaper clippings, etc., — and added them to what has become known as the Caldwell Archives, named after Ben and Betsy Caldwell. The couple had started this newer, less aggressive Bluffton movement by storing a wealth of historical documents in their home.

By 1988, the society’s mission had expanded. Realizing that the surviving buildings from the burning were slipping into decay, the group mobilized, placing historical markers on the 10 that remained. Shortly after, the society began purchasing as many of the properties as it could, turning the Heyward House into a museum as well as purchasing the ca. 1890 Colcock-Teel House.

And while the mission had expanded, that archive of Bluffton’s past first gathered in 1981 is still the society’s crown jewel. Moving forward, Fulgham wants to make sure those archives don’t go the way of those five houses that survived Union torches only to fall under the weight of time.

“We’re in the process of digitizing, inventorying, and safeguarding the archives. The importance of this project cannot be overemphasized,” he said. “We have original documents that exist nowhere else. When State Representative Bill Herbkersman heard of our efforts, he immediately sensed the magnitude of what we were doing and has since fought for state funding to support the BHPS mission. Preserving the archives literally translates into preservation of the BHPS. Without a central library and research center we would not really be a historical society.”

It’s a much different Bluffton than it was in 1981, and for the most part the original prediction that Bluffton might one day change forever has proven true. As Bluffton turns the page on its next chapter, Fulgham is making sure the society stays focused on its core principles.

“Bluffton is now a village of festivals, events, and social gatherings. This is not a bad thing for the BHPS, as long as we focus our efforts on our mission statement, which is to share Bluffton’s history with the public and to preserve it in the form of maintaining the Caldwell Archives and encouraging the preservation of historic buildings in the National Register District,” he said. “Successfully carrying out this mission takes a tremendous amount of time and effort and there are always distractions.”

But what sweet distractions they are. Whether it’s the Arts and Seafood Festival or just a Thursday Farmer’s Market, Bluffton’s many wonderful distractions always seem to rotate around the nucleus of its Old Town. And thanks to the diligent efforts of the BHPS, that Old Town presents a playground of authentic historical treasures, from the quiet grandeur of the Heyward House to the riverside majesty of Church of the Cross. It’s something that visitors have been quick to respond to.

“Not only do (visitors) share our appreciation for the town’s history, but, in many cases, their interest exceeds that of the locals,” said Fulgham. “I would like to encourage more locals to visit the Heyward House Historic Center and to come do research at the Caldwell Archives located at the Colcock-Teel House.”

Photos courtesy of the Bluffton Historical Society

Culture / Day Trips from Palmetto Bluff

Story by Barry Kaufman and Photographs by Lizzy Rollins Just beyond the gates of Palmetto Bluff, at the end of that quiet stretch of trees and sunlight, a solitary strip of pavement beckons. This connective tissue, a tributary, leads off across the great Amer...

Feb 2024
palmetto bluff

Real Estate / Behind the Bluff with Broker-in-Charge W. Bryan Byrne

Bryan’s Journey to Palmetto Bluff Real Estate In this edition of Behind the Bluff, W. Bryan Byrne, the Broker-in-Charge at Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company, discusses his two-decade journey in the community. His experience has intricately molded the authent...

Jan 2024
real estate in bluffton sc

Real Estate / Lowcountry Housing Trends & Market Updates

Real Estate in Bluffton, SC: Trends, Updates, and Insights Bluffton, South Carolina, nestled within the scenic Lowcountry, is not just a picturesque haven but also a thriving real estate market. As the demand for homes in this charming town continues to grow,...

Jan 2024

Food & Wine / Mocktails from the Palmetto Bluff Club

Rosemary Spice Mocktail Recipe Introducing Buffalos' exquisite Rosemary Spice Mocktail—a meticulously crafted blend that awakens the taste buds with a perfect harmony of bold flavors. Fresh jalapenos are muddled for a subtle spicy kick, while luscious cra...

Jan 2024

Artist in Residence / Painting Wild

Story by Sandy Lang and Photographs by Lawson Builder In early May, The Arts Initiative hosted renowned Lowcountry painter West Fraser as our esteemed Artist In Residence. Throughout his stay, residents were treated to an array of events, including a painting...

Jan 2024
palmetto buff golf course

Sporting Life / Behind the Bluff with the Palmetto Bluff 9-Hole Golf Course Team

All About the New Palmetto Bluff Golf Course Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Palmetto Bluff, a new golfing adventure is taking shape—the Crossroads 9-Hole Golf Course. To delve into the intricacies of this project, we had the opportunity to sit down w...

Dec 2023

Conservation / Palmetto Bluff Buffalo Run 2023: A Celebration of Endurance, Nature, and Community

A Recap of the 2034 Buffalo Run The Palmetto Bluff Buffalo Run celebrated its 10th anniversary on Sunday, December 11, 2023, drawing in a record-breaking crowd of over 500 runners. The event, nestled in the heart of Palmetto Bluff's 20,000 acres of natural sp...

Dec 2023
places to eat near hilton head

Food & Wine / Ask the Locals: Our Favorite Restaurants Near Hilton Head

The 10 Best Places to Eat Near Hilton Head Island Nestled on the southernmost tip of South Carolina, Hilton Head Island beckons not only with its pristine beaches but also with a culinary scene that rivals its natural beauty. The Lowcountry, known for breatht...

Dec 2023

Artist in Residence / Journey through Creativity: Palmetto Bluff's 2023 Artist in Residence Highlights

As the sun sets over the picturesque landscape of Palmetto Bluff, we are grateful for the creativity that took center stage throughout the year. The 2023 Artist in Residence program has ended, leaving behind a trail of artistic marvels and inspiring stories. F...

Dec 2023

Real Estate / The Builders Behind the Bluff

Meet the Palmetto Bluff Builders Team A home is more than just bricks and mortar; it's where cherished memories are made, and dreams come to life. At Palmetto Bluff, the Palmetto Bluff Builders team designs homes based on your vision.  Allow us to introduc...

Dec 2023
Community Villages
Palmetto Bluff Club
On The Water
The Arts Initiative
About Us