Real Estate // 7 min Read

Resale Case Study: How 70 Mount Pelia Road Set a Record

Written by Palmetto Bluff

Listen to the 70 Mount Pelia Road Case STudy

By W. Bryan Byrne, Broker-in-Charge
Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company

Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company represents sellers and buyers of resale homes and homesites throughout Palmetto Bluff, as well as the community’s developer offerings. Resale is a core part of our business. Our team brings the same on-the-ground knowledge to an existing home that we do to a new release.

A recent example is 70 Mount Pelia Road in May River Forest. We listed the home on June 29, 2026, and guided it through closing. It sold in 11 days for $6,175,000, which is the highest price ever paid for a non-waterfront home in Palmetto Bluff.

Below, we explain how we positioned the home, how we priced it, and what sellers of similar properties can learn from it.

70 Mount Pelia Road at a Glance

Address
70 Mount Pelia Road
Neighborhood
May River Forest
Bedrooms / Baths
4 | 4 1/2
Square Feet
4,636
List Price
$6,495,000
Sale Price
$6,175,000
Days on Market
11
Sale-To-List Ratio
95%
Price Per Square Foot
$1,332
Listing and Closing Agent
Bryan Byrne, Broker-in-Charge, Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company


How We Positioned the Home

The story of 70 Mount Pelia started with its setting. The homesite offers what we consider one of the best views in Palmetto Bluff that isn’t on the marsh or the river. That made it a rare opportunity, and we marketed it that way.

The layout mattered just as much. The property includes multiple structures, a main house and a guest house, both facing the view. That arrangement fits closely with what our network of generational buyers looks for: room for children, grandchildren, and guests, with privacy for everyone and a shared place to gather.

Launch-ready from day one

Every Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company listing goes to market only once all of its marketing assets are in place. That includes professional photography and video, a detailed marketing narrative, and rendered floor plans.

This matters most for premier listings. A “whisper campaign,” where a home is shown quietly to a few buyers before it is fully presented, rarely produces the best outcome for sellers. A complete, polished launch gives every qualified buyer the full picture at once. It also builds momentum in the first days on the market, and at 70 Mount Pelia, that momentum led to a contract in 11 days.


Pricing a One-of-a-Kind Property

Unique homes are hard to price because there are few true comparables. When recent sales don’t reflect what a property offers, a standard comparable-sales analysis can undervalue it. It can also leave buyers unsure whether the price is justified.

For properties like 70 Mount Pelia, we use a replication cost model. It answers a simple question: what would it cost a buyer to recreate this home on a similar homesite today? For this property, our estimate put the replication cost at or above the initial list price of $6,495,000.

That approach created a win for both sides. The seller had a clear, defensible basis for a premium price. The buyer could see they were paying no more than it would cost to build something comparable, without the time and uncertainty of design and construction.


The Result: A Palmetto Bluff Record

The home sold for $6,175,000 after 11 days on the market. That is 95% of the list price and $1,332 per square foot. It is the highest-priced non-waterfront home sale in Palmetto Bluff history.

The sale shows that a home without marsh or river frontage can set a record on its own merits. It takes the right homesite, a complete presentation, and a price grounded in real value.

Advice for Sellers and Buyers of One-of-a-Kind Homes

For sellers: make the purchase simple

Buyers drawn to a property like this are often busy, and the easier the purchase, the faster it tends to move. One effective step is to consider including some or all of the furnishings, especially pieces designed around the floor plan. Give those items a realistic value, so they support the deal rather than complicate the negotiation.

Selling Your Bluff Home with Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company

Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company works with resale clients every day. When we list your home, we represent you as the seller: your goals, your price, and your timeline.

Our agents know the community’s neighborhoods, homesites, and buyers firsthand. We know which views and floor plans are hardest to find, how to tell a property’s story, and how to reach buyers already searching for a home here. As 70 Mount Pelia Road shows, that knowledge translates into results.

If you’re thinking about selling your Palmetto Bluff home or homesite, contact our team to talk about your property and today’s market.

Real Estate
Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Market Report: 2026 Third Quarter Update

Since 2019, the average resale home price at Palmetto Bluff has more than doubled. That growth says a great deal about the market right now. Buyers continue to value what sets the Bluff apart, resale inventory remains limited, and the community keeps growing w...

Nov 2026

Food & Wine
Chef Rhy’s Roasted Butternut Squash Salad with Banana Pepper Vinaigrette

Originally featured in the bluff magazine’s F/W 2022 issue, Chef Rhy’s Roasted Butternut Squash Salad with Banana Pepper Vinaigrette celebrates the flavors of fall, combining roasted squash, wild mushrooms, and crisp baby gem lettuce with pickled mustard seeds...

Nov 2026

Conservation
The Secret Life of Clapper Rails

Discover the elusive marsh hen and its important role in the Lowcountry's salt marsh ecosystem. Along the winding waterways of Palmetto Bluff, the salt marsh is alive with activity. Fiddler crabs scurry across the mud, wading birds search the shallows for the...

Nov 2026

Culture
Fall Farmers Market

Celebrate the season at the Palmetto Bluff Fall Farmers Market! There's something special about autumn in the Lowcountry, and what better way to celebrate than with an afternoon of local shopping, seasonal flavors, and community at Palmetto Bluff? Join us on ...

Nov 2026

Artist in Residence
Beneath the Surface: Artist Brandon Finnorn at Palmetto Bluff

At the intersection of art and the natural world, Louisiana-based artist Brandon Finnorn found inspiration in the quiet beauty of the waters that shape our coastal landscapes. Through vibrant oil paintings capturing the movement, color, and intricate details o...

Oct 2026
palmetto bluff homes for sale

Real Estate
Five Available Palmetto Bluff Homes Made for the Season of Gathering

Inspired Spaces for the Season Ahead  At Palmetto Bluff, the holidays bring cooler evenings and a full calendar. Porches are decorated for holiday festivities, fireplaces stay lit, and the dining room table makes room for visiting family and friends. The home...

Oct 2026
palmetto bluff homes for sale

Real Estate
A Guide to the Bramble Park Home Plans at Palmetto Bluff

Inside the Homes of Bramble Park: Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Twelve homesites gather around a two-acre green in Moreland Forest, where native blackgum and loblolly pine shade a nature trail winding through the neighborhood. This is Bramble Park, Palmetto Bluf...

Oct 2026
palmetto bluff homes for sale

Real Estate
Palmetto Bluff Homes: Built for Longevity and Multigenerational Living

Palmetto Bluff Real Estate: Homes Built for Every Generation   Beneath Palmetto Bluff’s native live oaks, homes are built for generations, not just a single season. Cottages sit beside the primary home, designed for guests – whether visiting children, grandpa...

Oct 2026

Club Life
Wilson Village Welcomes The Chandlery

Tucked along picturesque Boat House Row in Palmetto Bluff’s iconic Wilson Village, The Chandlery offers a shopping experience inspired by the art of living well. This thoughtfully curated boutique brings together a unique collection of elegantly chic home furn...

Oct 2026

Club Life
Sit & Stay Awhile with the Latest Issue of the bluff Magazine

Fall is in the air as we welcome a new season at Palmetto Bluff. After a year marked by new beginnings and long-awaited plans coming to life, it feels only fitting to celebrate the final months of 2026 with the latest edition of the bluff magazine. The Fall...

Oct 2026

CURIOUS ABOUT LIFE AT THE BLUFF?

Sign up for our newsletter

LIVE
Community Villages
Experience
Palmetto Bluff Club
On The Water
The Arts Initiative
Events
Conserve
About Us