Food & Wine // 3 min Read

Making Better Bitters

Written by Palmetto Bluff

Apr 23, 2019

Every drink tells a story.

At Cole’s, it’s the story of Palmetto Bluff’s delicious natural bounty. It’s one thing to mix a drink. It’s another to tell a story in a glass, one written in delicate flavor notes and carefully chosen ingredients. step up to the bar at Cole’s and you’ll enjoy a drink that comes with a story written across generations of family tradition and steeped in ingredients grown right here in the wilds of Palmetto Bluff.

That storytelling, that dedication to crafting something beyond the ordinary, has long been a hallmark of Palmetto Bluff’s food and beverage teams. Their regular brainstorming sessions are rife with inspiration and ideas that push the boundaries of what their menus can be. During one of the regular brainstorming sessions among the resort’s food and beverage staff, Director of Wine Jesse Rodriguez’s simple request, “Look for the next best thing,” found fertile soil in the imagination of Cole’s Restaurant Manager Robin Whitaker.

“I’m a very firm believer that you don’t need to get everything off the shelf,” Whitaker said.
“My grandfather taught me to live off the land and make everything from scratch.”

In pursuit of the next best thing, Whitaker returned to childhood memories of wandering a North Carolina forest with her grandfather searching for ingredients. “That’s how I found out about sassafras. We’d go out around the grounds near his house, and I remember him pulling up this plant and asking him what he was doing. He said, ‘I’m going to make tea.’”

A young Whitaker watched as her grandfather peeled off the bark of the plant with practiced ease, sliced up the roots, and simmered it for 20 minutes to release its naturally sweet flavors. That cup of sassafras tea, brewed from a plant her grandfather pulled from the ground, bubbled up in Whitaker’s memory as she pursued the next best thing. Thanks to the miracle of modern technology that is YouTube, she found a multitude of instructional videos on foraging ingredients to create bespoke bitters. This artisanal touch not only allowed Whitaker to gain even more control over the flavor profile, but it also provided the perfect way to to lend an air of homegrown authenticity to her beverage list.

“We do have around 20,000 acres here at Palmetto Bluff, and that’s a lot of forest for foraging ingredients,” Whitaker said. “That’s when I emailed Jay (Walea) and told him I wanted to make root bitters, so I was going to need sassafras.”

She couldn’t have found a better guide for her foraging. For more than 25 years, Walea has stewarded the land at Palmetto Bluff, going back to its days as a retreat for Union Camp executives. If there is anyone who would know where to find the most flavorful herbs, roots, and leaves for Cole’s cocktails, it would be Jay. The two of them began planning regular retreats far afield in search of ingredients, plying the deer trails and tracks through Palmetto Bluff’s wilderness and sampling flavors along the way.

Beyond the sassafras that Whitaker says grows rampantly within the Bluff’s forests, she and Walea have plucked blackberry leaves, intensely bitter devil’s club root, and sweetleaves that pack an intense Granny Smith apple flavor. With each plant they uncover, Whitaker’s wheels turn with ideas for how each could complement a beverage.

“I’ve always felt every restaurant needs their own specific drink,” Whitaker said. One of her favorites is the Cole’s Fashioned, created with orange bitters she blends daily inside a large kettle within Cole’s liquor cage. The kettle shortens a 22-day process of soaking ingredients in Everclear-filled Mason jars to a four-hour low simmer that coaxes flavors to the forefront.

“This accelerated process heats up the alcohol to
106 degrees, which is the magic temperature. It doesn’t burn off the alcohol, but it extracts flavor a lot more.”

As the weather warms up and Whitaker heads back out with Walea in search of the next best thing, keep your eyes on Cole’s drink menu. The next cocktail you enjoy might just have its roots in your own backyard.


Cole’s Fashioned

2.5 oz. Virgil Kaine ginger bourbon

A “scoach” of simple syrup

Luxardo cherries

Orange slice

House-made orange bitters

Muddle bourbon and simple syrup with Luxardo cherries and orange slice. Add two dashes of house-made orange bitters. Add ice. Garnish with brûléed orange slice.


Photography by Krisztian Lonyai

palmetto bluff

Real Estate / Behind the Bluff with Broker-in-Charge W. Bryan Byrne

Bryan’s Journey to Palmetto Bluff Real Estate In this edition of Behind the Bluff, W. Bryan Byrne, the Broker-in-Charge at Palmetto Bluff Real Estate Company, discusses his two-decade journey in the community. His experience has intricately molded the authent...

Jan 2024
real estate in bluffton sc

Real Estate / Lowcountry Housing Trends & Market Updates

Real Estate in Bluffton, SC: Trends, Updates, and Insights Bluffton, South Carolina, nestled within the scenic Lowcountry, is not just a picturesque haven but also a thriving real estate market. As the demand for homes in this charming town continues to grow,...

Jan 2024

Food & Wine / Mocktails from the Palmetto Bluff Club

Rosemary Spice Mocktail Recipe Introducing Buffalos' exquisite Rosemary Spice Mocktail—a meticulously crafted blend that awakens the taste buds with a perfect harmony of bold flavors. Fresh jalapenos are muddled for a subtle spicy kick, while luscious cra...

Jan 2024

Artist in Residence / Painting Wild

Story by Sandy Lang and Photographs by Lawson Builder In early May, The Arts Initiative hosted renowned Lowcountry painter West Fraser as our esteemed Artist In Residence. Throughout his stay, residents were treated to an array of events, including a painting...

Jan 2024
palmetto buff golf course

Sporting Life / Behind the Bluff with the Palmetto Bluff 9-Hole Golf Course Team

All About the New Palmetto Bluff Golf Course Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Palmetto Bluff, a new golfing adventure is taking shape—the Crossroads 9-Hole Golf Course. To delve into the intricacies of this project, we had the opportunity to sit down w...

Dec 2023

Conservation / Palmetto Bluff Buffalo Run 2023: A Celebration of Endurance, Nature, and Community

A Recap of the 2034 Buffalo Run The Palmetto Bluff Buffalo Run celebrated its 10th anniversary on Sunday, December 11, 2023, drawing in a record-breaking crowd of over 500 runners. The event, nestled in the heart of Palmetto Bluff's 20,000 acres of natural sp...

Dec 2023
places to eat near hilton head

Food & Wine / Ask the Locals: Our Favorite Restaurants Near Hilton Head

The 10 Best Places to Eat Near Hilton Head Island Nestled on the southernmost tip of South Carolina, Hilton Head Island beckons not only with its pristine beaches but also with a culinary scene that rivals its natural beauty. The Lowcountry, known for breatht...

Dec 2023

Artist in Residence / Journey through Creativity: Palmetto Bluff's 2023 Artist in Residence Highlights

As the sun sets over the picturesque landscape of Palmetto Bluff, we are grateful for the creativity that took center stage throughout the year. The 2023 Artist in Residence program has ended, leaving behind a trail of artistic marvels and inspiring stories. F...

Dec 2023

Real Estate / The Builders Behind the Bluff

Meet the Palmetto Bluff Builders Team A home is more than just bricks and mortar; it's where cherished memories are made, and dreams come to life. At Palmetto Bluff, the Palmetto Bluff Builders team designs homes based on your vision.  Allow us to introduc...

Dec 2023

Well Living at Montage Palmetto Bluff

Story by Meghan Lamb A life well lived is a life full of connection and rich experiences. It is about embracing the present moment, exploring new horizons, and nurturing the mind, body, and spirit. One such lifestyle can be found at Montage Palmetto Bluff, a ...

Dec 2023
Community Villages
Palmetto Bluff Club
On The Water
The Arts Initiative
About Us