Food & Wine // 1 min Read

Bill Smith’s Atlantic Beach Pie

Written by Palmetto Bluff

Iconic Southern restaurant Crook’s Corner still serves former executive chef Bill Smith’s legendary Atlantic Beach Pie. The perfect hybrid of a key lime pie and lemon meringue pie, it’s light and bright, but also incredibly rich and delicious. The pie is prepared with a lemon-lime filling made with condensed milk, and it’s served in a saltine cracker crust for a sweet and salty indulgence. It’s served cold, but not before being finished with fresh whipped cream.

CRUST INGREDIENTS:
• 3 sleeves saltine crackers
• 6 tbsp sugar
• ½ lb. unsalted butter, softened

FILLING INGREDIENTS:
• 8 egg yolks
• 2 cans sweetened condensed milk
• ½ cup fresh lemon juice
• ½ cup fresh lime juice

DIRECTIONS:
1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Crush the crackers into a coarse meal. I use my hands if I am only making one recipe and a food processor if I am making a lot. Mix in the sugar, then knead in the butter. Butter varies, so sometimes you may need a little more. It should hold together sort of like a crumbly dough. Press into two pie pans and chill. When set, bake for 17 minutes. The crust should color a tiny bit.

2. While the crusts are baking, beat the filling ingredients together very well. When the crusts are done, pour in the filling. You don’t need to wait for them to cool. Bake for another 15 minutes or until the pies are set at the center.

3. The pies need to chill before they can be cut. Serve with lightly sweetened, fresh whipped cream sprinkled with coarse sea salt.


Pie photo courtesy of Lissa Gotwals. Headshot by Soleil Konkel.

%GALLERY%

Culture
Wild Island

This Manhattan-sized, Gilded Age enclave and National Seashore off the Florida-Georgia coast is so much more than a beachcomber’s delight.  By Alexandra Marvar “There’s one. Oh, and there’s one.” He bends down to pick up a shark tooth. Then another, and anot...

Jul 2025
south carolina food

Food & Wine
A Foodie’s Guide to the South Carolina Lowcountry

Best Things to Eat in South Carolina’s Lowcountry When it comes to Southern cuisine, no place captures the heart (and appetite) quite like the South Carolina Lowcountry. Rooted in history and layered with coastal influence, this region serves up a culinary id...

Jul 2025
palmetto bluff marissa wolf

Culture
Behind the Bluff with Membership Manager: Marissa Wolf

Marissa’s Journey to Palmetto Bluff At Palmetto Bluff, hospitality goes beyond service; it’s a way of life. For Members and visitors alike, there’s a quiet charm to the place that draws you in, makes you feel at ease, and leaves a lasting impression. Few peop...

Jul 2025

Culture
Paradise Found: Hidden Nature Trails in Palmetto Bluff

Top 7 Palmetto Bluff Nature Trails Do you ever get the feeling of wanting to escape and wander into a serene paradise? The nature trails at Palmetto Bluff afford opportunities to roam and admire the vastness of the Bluff’s 20,000 acres. Throughout the communi...

Jun 2025

Architecture & Design
Moreland Village: Laid Back Luxury

Palmetto Bluff’s Moreland Village feels a world away from the more traditional architecture of the iconi...

Jun 2025

Culture
2025 Inspiring the Arts Scholarship Recipients

We are thrilled to introduce the inaugural winners of the Inspiring the Arts Scholarship—three extraordinary young women pursuing their artistic dreams through higher education! Katherine Donahue has been named our first official scholarship recipient, with Em...

Jun 2025

Culture
Summer Style in the Bluff: Discover What’s New in Retail

From handmade jewelry to performance wear, the latest arrivals at Palmetto Bluff’s retail spots capture the season in true Lowcountry style. This summer, the Bluff’s shops are full of fresh finds, carefully chosen by our trusted retailers—including FLOW Galler...

Jun 2025

Conservation
Citizen Science

Citizen Science is Thriving at Palmetto BluffDid you know that residents of Palmetto Bluff are playing a vital role in national and global conservation efforts—all from their backyard?Through the Palmetto Bluff Conservancy’s growing Citizen Science programs, c...

Jun 2025

Artist in Residence
Music Mosaic

In October 2024, Grammy Award-winning musician Clay Ross visited Palmetto Bluff as part of The Arts Initiative's Artist in Residence Program. Through storytelling and song, he explores identity, heritage, and the universal language of sound. By Barry Kaufman ...

Jun 2025

Food & Wine
Peach Perfect

Palmetto Bluff Club Executive Chef  Beth Cosgrove and Director of Culinary, Chef Rhy Waddington, Cook Up Four Peachy Recipes for a Summer in the South. Is there anything more iconic than a southern peach? A symbol of summer and Southern heritage, the peach car...

Jun 2025

CURIOUS ABOUT LIFE AT THE BLUFF?

Sign up for our newsletter

LIVE
Community Villages
Experience
Palmetto Bluff Club
On The Water
The Arts Initiative
Events
Conserve
About Us